Brian Roberts deserves better from the fans

Tell friends
Roberts and Markakis

Orioles fans are an angry lot. I get that. What I don't get is the displaced - or more accurately stated, misplaced - anger currently being heaped upon injured second baseman Brian Roberts. Be frustrated about the guy's injury history, sure, but my advice to my fellow O's faithful would be to withhold judgment on his current status until we really know what's going on with the team's longest-tenured player. He's earned as much.

It's never wise to use the comments section of any website, even a newspaper's, to gauge popular opinion on a topic. Nevertheless, it surprised me to see the animosity directed toward Roberts in The Sun's comments section after he announced the cancellation of Brian's Baseball Bash, his annual fundraiser for the University of Maryland children's hospital.

Some fans seem to think that Roberts is lazy, disinterested, resting on his laurels, and/or big-timing it as he faces an injury that has affected his career and which could apparently affect his life away from the game as well. 

Here's a sampling of those comments:

"There's no way this 'concussion' would prevent him from hosting this event. He played hard for us all these years but I think the money has ruined him."

"Roberts doesn't appear to feel any obligation to show up for anything these days. Just keep cashing those checks, B-Rob..."

"Brian has literally stolen money from this team the last 2 years. If the truth be told if doesn't even want to play this game again. He always reminded me of eddie haskell on leave it to beaver, put on a good show around Mrs and Mr cleaver but was a jerk when nobody was around. Funny how things work out Both him and Nick were the golden boy's and pet players of Peter A and they both completely have stolen money to the tune of 100 million from him."

"BooHoo Brian...there's plenty of GIs serving in Afghanistan right now that suffered Traumatic Brain Injuries and returned to duty far quicker for a hell of lot less money. The difference between them and Brian? Out of sense of duty they want to. Take a trip to Walter Reed or Bethesda if you're worried about charity. i have a hard time feeling sorry for these cheating Prima Donas. Especially when they suck. Give back the $10M or get your a$$ on the field and suck it up or retire."

It's not just the fans. In a rather ironic move, a rather thin-skined local reporter took a shot at Roberts during the week via Twitter, minimizing his concussion by comparing it to Ravens linebacker Sergio Kindle's cracked skull. The Tweet was later deleted.

Roberts can't win for trying in Baltimore. First it was the allegation that he was dogging it on the field, now it's the suggestion that he's giving his charity work short shrift. He answered the former allegation last season by providing a much-need spark to the lineup in the season's second half and demonstrating that the O's are a different team when he's healthy.

That type of effort is why so many people were excited when the Birds extended Roberts' contract in 2009. Consider what one fan wrote back then in a much kinder Sun comments section: "It's looking pretty much unanimous so far and I'll join the chorus, great signing! I breathed a big sigh of relief reading it." (See the difference in comments for yourself.)

These things we know about Roberts:

-He's a solid baseball player when healthy.

-He's done extensive charity work in the community for much of his career.

-He's served as the face of a downtrodden franchise and decided to stay the course when leaving would've been the easier, and potentially more lucrative, move.

This we don't know: the full extent of his current injury.

Brian Roberts has earned the benefit of the doubt from fans, some of whom have instead chosen to judge his character from afar. It's okay to hate the situation, but don't hate the man going through it.



I think the frustration of

Submitted by Lucas (not verified) on Mon, 2011-08-15 11:53.

I think the frustration of the fans is not that he is injured as much as he has not been honest the last 2 years about what is going on. I can't tell you how many articles I read where B-Rob would say " I just tweaked my (fill in injured area), I should be good in a couple days" or "it's day-to-day" only to have him be out for weeks at a time. Brian seems like a nice guy and its great that he does a ton of charity work in the area, but its hard to get excited or support someone when they won't be honest with you. It would be nice for him to say "I injured my back/ head and it's not looking good. I am going to try and get back as soon as possible but I don't know how long that will be". My personal belief as to why he cancelled the event is that he does not want to have to keep answering questions from people (angry or concerned) about his health and would rather reschedule to a time that he is healthy and doesn't have to answer the same questions over and over.


Submitted by gavin1177 (not verified) on Mon, 2011-08-15 08:12.

For me the anger is that he is obviously breaking down due to the use of steroids. Unlike some of the other comments I don't think he is "not playing hard" due to the insane contract he received. He used steroids and now he is breaking down. I think his injuries are real. The steroid use is killing his body and he can't stay healthy. Enjoy your 40mil B-Rob - hold as many "Birthday Bash's" you want. You've robbed the organization and the fans.

Post new comment

(If you're a human, don't change the following field)
Your first name.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.